How to Give Feedback in an Annual Review

Ah, the annual review—a time when managers and employees come together to discuss accomplishments, growth opportunities, and, of course, feedback. But how do you navigate the delicate dance of giving feedback as a manager? 💃🏼😬

I’ve got you! ✨

In this ultimate guide, I’ll show you how to master the art of ~constructive feedback~ while providing employees with genuine support. Let’s dive right in! 👇🏼👇🏼

The Power of Positivity:

Feedback doesn't have to be all doom and gloom. Start your annual review on a positive note by acknowledging your employee's strengths, accomplishments, and contributions 🎉🌈 Highlight specific instances where they excelled and express genuine appreciation for their hard work. By setting a positive tone, you create a foundation of trust and openness for the rest of the conversation 🏅 Plus, it feels good to be acknowledged for your work.

Be Specific and Objective:

Vague feedback is like a riddle that nobody wants to solve 🧩 When providing feedback, be specific and objective about the areas that need improvement. Focus on concrete examples and behaviors that demonstrate the need for growth. This helps your employee understand exactly what they need to work on and provides a clear path forward 🚀

The Sandwich Technique:

Sometimes, wrapping constructive feedback in a fluffy bun 🥐 can make it more digestible. Employ the sandwich technique, where you sandwich constructive criticism between two layers of positive feedback. Start with something positive, provide constructive feedback, and end on another positive note 🥪 This approach softens the impact of criticism and shows that you genuinely care about their development.

Active Listening and Open Dialogue:

An annual review should never be a one-sided conversation. Encourage active listening by giving your employee ample time to share their perspective, concerns, and goals. Create a safe space for open dialogue where they can ask questions and seek clarification. Remember, effective feedback is a two-way street that fosters mutual understanding and growth.

Set Clear Goals and Offer Support:

Feedback without a roadmap is like a GPS without directions 😵‍💫 Help your employee chart their path to success by setting clear, actionable goals 💫 Collaborate with them to develop a plan that outlines the steps needed to overcome challenges and achieve growth. Additionally, offer your support, guidance, and resources to assist them on their journey. After all, you want to see them succeed, don’t you? 

Giving feedback during annual reviews should be a transformative experience for both you and your employees 🦋 You want to sound positive and supportive while also communicating opportunities for growth. Because at the end of the day, annual reviews are not just about pointing out flaws but also about recognizing achievements, setting goals, and fostering growth. So, go forth and be the feedback champion your team deserves! 🏆

👉🏼 If you’re looking for more in-depth guidance on becoming a standout applicant, take my Career Workshop Intensive, a 4-part program designed to help you get a job you love ASAP.